Rumination and thought suppression may link intolerance of uncertainty to anxiety and depression
A three-wave longitudinal study found that two emotion regulation strategies, one with a surprising effect, help explain how intolerance of uncertainty relates to later anxiety and depression.
Some people have such a strong aversion to the unknown that they experience it as distressing and threatening. Intolerance of uncertainty has been proposed as a transdiagnostic factor in several emotional disorders. These include generalised anxiety disorder, major depressive disorder, social anxiety disorder, panic disorder and agoraphobia. How it leads to emotional difficulties remains unclear. Sahib and colleagues at the Australian National University tested one candidate explanation, the way people regulate their emotions.
Theoretical models propose that people who are intolerant of uncertainty manage the resulting emotions with strategies such as rumination, avoidance and reassurance seeking, which contribute to their difficulties. Earlier studies testing this were mostly cross-sectional and covered only a few strategies. They usually tested strategies one at a time, even though people often use several in combination.
The study
The team followed 341 adults living in English-speaking countries across three online surveys. The surveys were six weeks apart, between July 2022 and March 2023, and 273 people completed the third wave. Participants’ average age was 37 and 54.4% were women. The study was preregistered.
At the first wave, participants completed measures of intolerance of uncertainty, anxiety and depression. At the second, they reported how much they used eight emotion regulation strategies. Three were classed as adaptive, namely mindfulness, cognitive reappraisal and problem-solving. Five were classed as maladaptive, namely rumination, thought suppression, experiential avoidance, cognitive avoidance and reassurance seeking. At the third wave, anxiety and depression were measured again. All eight strategies were analysed together, controlling for people’s earlier anxiety or depression.
What they found
Higher intolerance of uncertainty predicted greater use of four maladaptive strategies six weeks later. These were experiential avoidance, thought suppression, rumination and reassurance seeking. It did not predict lower use of the adaptive strategies.
Turning to the third wave:
greater mindfulness and cognitive reappraisal predicted lower anxiety and depression
problem-solving predicted lower depression
rumination predicted higher anxiety and depression
thought suppression, unexpectedly, predicted lower anxiety and depression
Two strategies emerged as pathways. Higher intolerance of uncertainty predicted more rumination, which in turn predicted higher anxiety and depression. It also predicted more thought suppression, which in turn predicted lower anxiety and depression. Intolerance of uncertainty did not directly predict later depression.
Making sense of suppression
The suppression result runs against earlier cross-sectional research linking thought suppression to higher anxiety and depression. The authors offer two possible explanations. First, all eight strategies were modelled together. The variance suppression shares with other strategies, such as rumination, may have been captured by those strategies, leaving a part of suppression that reflects a more “successful” or adaptive process. Second, drawing on ideas about emotion regulation flexibility, suppression may function differently in uncertain contexts and become more adaptive there.
The authors also note that the four strategies predicted by intolerance of uncertainty fit a pattern described in earlier work as aversive cognitive perseveration. This involves difficulty disengaging from negative thoughts, alongside rejecting and avoiding negative internal experiences.
Implications and limitations
The authors suggest that interventions for people who are intolerant of uncertainty should prioritise rumination and thought suppression as specific targets for change.
They are clear about the study’s limits. The sample was not large enough for a cross-lagged analysis, so the direction of causality cannot be established. Anxiety and depression measures overlap considerably. The study did not distinguish between people with and without psychological disorders, and most participants (82.4%) identified as White. All measures were self-report. The authors call for experimental research, such as manipulating rumination or thought suppression, to test whether these strategies play a causal role.
Reference: Sahib, A., Chen, J., Cárdenas, D., Calear, A. L., & Wilson, C. (2024). Emotion regulation mediates the relation between intolerance of uncertainty and emotion difficulties: A longitudinal investigation. Journal of Affective Disorders, 364, 194–204. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2024.08.056

.jpg)

Comments