top of page

People who crave predictability may find avoidance harder to let go

Oct 17
3 min read

A laboratory experiment in Spain found that people higher in prospective intolerance of uncertainty avoided more, adjusted less when an unpleasant outcome was made milder, and kept avoiding for longer.


Keeping your distance from a threatening dog is sensible. As Flores and colleagues point out, though, if that avoidance stops responding to what actually happens, a person can end up fearing any dog or avoiding any place connected with dogs. Excessive avoidance has been linked to obsessive-compulsive disorder, social anxiety disorder, generalised anxiety disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder. This study asked whether intolerance of uncertainty makes people more prone to it.


The team focused on prospective intolerance of uncertainty, described as the “desire for predictability and an active engagement in seeking certainty”. This differs from inhibitory intolerance of uncertainty, the “paralysis of cognition and action in the face of uncertainty”.


The experiment

A week before the experiment, 156 undergraduates from the Faculty of Psychology at the University of Málaga completed the Intolerance of Uncertainty Scale and a measure of trait anxiety. In the lab, they wore headphones and watched abstract fractal images. Two images signalled that an unpleasant sound might play in the left or right ear. The sound came on half of those trials, at an unpredictable moment. A third image was safe and was never followed by a sound.


Participants were then told they could avoid the sound by pressing a key, as often as they liked. They got no immediate feedback, so they could only be completely certain they had avoided the sound once the image disappeared.


Half the participants were then told the sound linked to one image would now stay at low volume. It dropped from about 97 to 27 decibels. In the final test phase, no sounds were played at all. If people tracked the change, they should press less for the image linked to the quieter sound. The other half were a control group who heard a loud and a quiet sound from the start. After excluding 21 people who made no responses to the sound cues early in the test phase, 135 participants were analysed.


What they found

Among those who experienced the volume drop, higher prospective intolerance of uncertainty was associated with:

  • less sensitivity to the change, so they kept responding to the cue for the now-quiet sound much as they did to the cue for the loud one

  • more avoidance responses overall while learning the task

  • more responses to the safe image, which had never been followed by a sound

  • greater resistance to extinction, meaning avoidance persisted for longer once no sounds were played


For insensitivity to the change and for responses to the safe image, these links held after controlling for trait anxiety. Trait anxiety no longer predicted either outcome. For the overall amount of avoidance, the two could not be disentangled. Inhibitory intolerance of uncertainty was not related to sensitivity to the change.


The pattern did not appear to reflect a general difficulty adjusting to louder versus quieter sounds. Prospective intolerance of uncertainty was unrelated to sensitivity in the control group. Nor was it explained by differences in learning which image predicted which sound, in how unpleasant the sound felt, or in trust in the instructions.


Exploratory analyses suggested two further links. The higher rate of avoidance partly accounted for the reduced sensitivity, and reduced sensitivity in turn accounted for the greater resistance to extinction. The authors suggest that insensitivity may stop people noticing that a cue is no longer followed by the sound.


What it means

The authors say that, as far as they know, this is the first time a link between prospective intolerance of uncertainty and excessive, inflexible avoidance has been detected experimentally in healthy participants. They suggest intolerance of uncertainty could help identify people at risk of anxiety disorders, and that prevention programmes could aim to reduce it.


They leave open whether this avoidance reflects habit or a goal-directed strategy to reduce uncertainty, and they note several limitations. Pressing a key costs very little, unlike many real-world avoidance behaviours. A general intolerance of uncertainty scale may miss domain-specific intolerance, since some high scorers might have tolerated uncertainty about a noise quite well. Desire for control was not measured, and they suggest future studies include it.


Reference: Flores, A., López, F. J., Vervliet, B., & Cobos, P. L. (2018). Intolerance of uncertainty as a vulnerability factor for excessive and inflexible avoidance behavior. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 104, 34–43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brat.2018.02.008

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


ABOUT US >

Founded in 1983, ISSID explores individual differences and publishes scientific papers in Personality and Individual Differences.

Subscribe to our newsletter

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

© 2024 by ISSID

bottom of page