Could intolereance of uncertainty start in the body?
A theoretical paper from Newcastle University proposes that the physical feeling of not knowing, and how people read that feeling, sits at the heart of intolerance of uncertainty.

The Intolerance of Uncertainty Scale was first developed at Université Laval in Québec to help understand worry and generalised anxiety disorder. Interest in the construct has since spread to other anxiety disorders, physical health, neuroimaging, medical training and even tourism. In this paper, Mark Freeston and Jessica Komes step back and ask what intolerance of uncertainty is “other than what is measured by the scale(s)”.
They begin by taking stock. The research shows consistent links between intolerance of uncertainty and distress. There is growing evidence that it is distinct from related constructs. Longitudinal and treatment studies give some evidence that it comes before later difficulties. The authors note that replication and extension are still needed.
From threat to safety
A key influence on their thinking is Brosschot and colleagues’ Generalized Unsafety Theory of Stress. This theory argues, on evolutionary grounds, that the default state is heightened arousal, held in check by the presence of safety. The absence of threat is not the same as the presence of safety, so people can feel unsafe without any threat at all. Seen this way, the question reverses. It is no longer how people become intolerant of uncertainty, but how some people become more tolerant than others.
A signal from the body
The second influence is the somatic error theory of anxiety proposed by Khalsa and Feinstein in 2018. In this theory, anxiety arises from a mismatch between the body state the brain predicts and the one it registers. Small mismatches are normal and help refine future predictions. Large ones require corrective action.
Freeston and Komes combine these ideas into what they call the somatic error theory of intolerance of uncertainty, described in this paper for the first time. When a situation contains something unknown, the body produces an internal signal that, at its simplest, says “something is different”. Some people may find this intriguing, an opening into unexplored territory. Others, especially people with longstanding difficulties characterised by anxiety, may conclude that “something must be wrong”.
One way to quiet that uncomfortable signal is to find a threat. A threat can be located and dealt with, usually by avoiding or escaping it, and the uncertainty shrinks. The cost, the authors argue, is that the felt sense of uncertainty itself goes unexamined. Unhelpful ways of interpreting bodily signals are reinforced across situations. They suggest this may partly explain why intolerance of uncertainty is linked to so many different disorders.
The authors then push the logic further. Perceived threat might be secondary, or even an epiphenomenon, rather than the ultimate cause of anxiety. Freeston notes that after thirty or more years invested in threat-based models of anxiety, he finds himself entertaining this possibility. The authors describe the idea as “highly speculative”.
Testing and applying the idea
The paper sets out testable predictions. Inducing a felt sense of uncertainty without threat should intensify emotional responses. People high in intolerance of uncertainty might prefer a clear explanation of a known, mildly negative outcome over more uncertain information about possibly positive ones. The authors call for a standard way of inducing uncertainty without threat, perhaps an app or online game. They also call for research into whether uncertainty has a characteristic bodily sensation or posture.
Clinically, they suggest that people could learn to recognise their habitual responses by deliberately experiencing uncertainty without threat. One example is the children’s game “pop-up pirate”, which has been used in a group-based treatment in primary care. They also argue for playfulness. Where someone’s circumstances are genuinely unsafe, addressing that unsafety may need to come first. This could mean re-establishing routines, a realistic sense of the future, and contact with valued activities.
This is a theoretical paper and reports no new data. It ends with the hope that, by “making friends with uncertainty”, people might approach the unknown with curiosity rather than assuming the worst. In the authors’ words, uncertainty “can be tolerated, perhaps accepted, and even embraced”.
Reference: Freeston, M., & Komes, J. (2023). Revisiting uncertainty as a felt sense of unsafety: The somatic error theory of intolerance of uncertainty. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 79, Article 101827. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbtep.2022.101827

.jpg)

Comments